| CATEGORY: Free Verse |
|
Swan Lake
Swan Lake She had elegance and poise … on the surface at least. A deceptive calm; swanlike. Beneath, a desperate struggle, against undercurrents known only to her and others in the same water. She wasn’t sure if the water was too hot, or too cold. Neither did she see the shore; she couldn’t see it... yet she seemed, to her friends, to walk there, with an air of confidence; pristine in appearance. To face the outside world she boiled pans to wash her clothes by hand. To hide from her inner world she wrote, poetry, and she read, but never the mail; those words would crumble her fragile veneer. Still, unopened, they remained a malignant threat, silently growing. She had paid, hard earned money; planned, for times such as these. Insurances; protection plans; vaccinations against the virus of poverty, but she hadn’t planned on being trapped by the so-called
welfare state.
There was never any immunity.
by bluemoon (Viewed 445 times) Show Brief Description
| You must log-on in order to critique and grade any writings. Login here. |
| Other Critiques of this Work |
| Given By: |  pulltheletter
|
| Critique Date: | 12/11/2009 |
|
| Critique: | Very well written and said. Thanks for sharing! |
|
|
| Grade: |  |
| Given By: |  raenie
|
| Critique Date: | 09/18/2009 |
|
| Critique: | Hi Sharon :) like what Katina said, this is a very unique write in the sense that it segued seamlessly from something that seemed like a poem about fantasy to reality--and the reader was taken unknowingly into that ride...I really liked your metaphor for water--In the world we live in, we could either sink or swim and much like the crab (hmm is it a crab?) which doesn't know that it's getting killed gradually by the hot water--sometimes, we too can become numb by the changes in our economy and don't know that we are already suffering, ie with the increase in inflation--hehe I hope I'm not getting too technical here--I really appreciate this thought-provoking write since it is very timely and a lot can relate to this--we all have our masks I guess, but at the end of the day, we all have to take them off...I just have a wee comment on your commas--somehow I felt that there was too much of it, that it sometimes interrupted the flow of thought--unless it was intentional, to ease things gradually into the next line...just a thought...otherwise---a very intriguing style you used here--your creativity is boundless--& I'm so happy we reap the benefits of it ;) thanks again for sharing... |
| [View Replies] |
|
| Grade: |  |
| Given By: |  kuirq
|
| Critique Date: | 09/18/2009 |
|
| Critique: | This is a really interesting read all through out. First of all, the title made me curious what tale you will share (I haven't seen "Swan Lake, by the way, and so I just have a vague idea of what it's about). The first four stanzas seemed to be of something mystical, and then the 5th made me curious as to where you'll bring the story, having made me realize that you were veering towards something mundane. I don't often read poems such as these that are so specific, and not just generally speak about love, loss or the forever broad theme of life. It has a certain appeal since it zones in on something so particular, that everyone can still relate to (although we don't particularly have that issue that I'm aware of here). I agree with Nikko about the commas (and semi-colons), perhaps you could exchange some for ellipses or maybe even enter the next line (e.g. but she hadn't planned....)? But then again, perhaps it might lessen the impact of the last line? By the way, I liked the anonymity, I think it will be easier for the reader to see themselves as being spoken of, of realizing that the situation being described is exactly what she is going through. Thanks, Sharon for a different take on poetry writing, it's always intriguing what you'll come up with next! |
| [View Replies] |
|
| Grade: |  |
| Given By: |  Katina
|
| Critique Date: | 09/17/2009 |
|
| Critique: | The most intriguing piece of poetry I've read in a long time. What gave this poem such a new flavor is the theme. The poem began like a (somewhat typical) poem, using elements such as fiction, a mermaid came to mind upon reading the first few stanzas, (which I enjoyed immensely!). ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The alteration and internal rhyme well executed, and then it transformed into a poem about a woman (some thing real), a person who had been careful saving money all of their life, then one day wake up and realize that they had to put down their pride to ask for help through an economic hardship.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I understood what the poem meant, and how easy it is to show a crisp smile on the surface, but feel the tears behind the eyes, when no one is looking. How life seems ordinary to those we know, yet, it is not so ordinary, the pain is there, and the poverty can be far too close to home. This is a valuable poem Sharon that I think should be published. There were a few areas that seemed a bit forced (or) maybe not. It has to do with using the pronoun: she in a lot of places, I think omitting some of the uses of the word: she may help to enhance the poem. Another idea is to give the character a name later on in the poem, from a fictitious she in swan lake to a real person.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since you are building character through out the piece, what better way to make a person seem real in a poem or story then to give them a name. You are a superb poet Sharon. I only see great things for you in your writing career. Outstanding. This write can also be considered Lyric (and you may want to submit it to that contest we talked about). One idea for now. Excellent work! |
| [View Replies] |
|
| Grade: |  |
|